Pulau Pinang

Pulau Pinang
1
Ranking
Transparency
0 /100
Transparency

(Open Budget Index Score)

Public Participation
0 /100
Oversight

The Malaysia Open Budget Index (MyOBI) assessment measures state budget transparency through the availability and quality of data in four key budget documents: the Executive Budget Proposal (EBP), Enacted Budget (EB), Year-End Report (YER), and Audit Report (AR). A budget document is considered publicly available if members of the public can access the document free of charge from the internet.

61-100

Substantial information

41-60

Minimal information

0-40

Insufficient information

Document Availability Score

Key Budget Documents

Purpose and Contents of Budget Documents

Document Availability Score

Buku Belanjawan Negeri 2022, Rang Undang-Undang Perbekalan 2022, Budget Speech

Executive Budget Proposal

The EBP lays out the proposed budget plan for the forthcoming year, which is submitted to the state assembly for approval. The EBP comprises the budget speech, the finance bill, and the estimates of revenue and expenditure.

44

Enakmen Rang Undang-Undang Perbekalan Negeri 2022

Enacted Budget

Following the EBP’s approval by the state assembly, the EB is the legal mandate for the government to provide the finalised details of the budget plan.

0

Penyata Kewangan Kerajaan Negeri 2022

Year-End Report

The YER reports on the implementation and financial performance of the budget plan throughout the fiscal year.

67

Laporan Ketua Audit Negara Mengenai Penayata Kewangan Kerajaan Negeri dan Agensi Negeri serta Pengauditan Pematuhan Jabatan/Agensi Negeri 2022

Audit Report

The AR is an independent evaluation of the accuracy of the financial statements of the government, and its compliance with financial management laws and regulations. It is produced by the National Audit Department.

67

Oversight Mechanism

Oversight Mechanism

Was the 2024 Executive Budget Proposal tabled?

Y

Did the State Assembly approve the 2024 Executive Budget Proposal?

Y

Was the 2024 Enacted Budget made public?

N

Was the 2020 Audit Report laid out to the State Assembly?

Y

Did a committee of the State Assembly (Public Accounts Committee) examine the 2021 Audit Report?

NA

How many days did the State Assembly sit in 2021?

12

Y

Yes

N

No

NA

Information Not Available

Past Records

Pulau Pinang

Pulau Pinang

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

More...

Selangor

Selangor

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

Perlis

Perlis

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

Kedah

Kedah

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

Perak

Perak

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

Selangor

Selangor

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

Perlis

Perlis

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

Kedah

Kedah

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

Perak

Perak

Assess the budget transparency of state governments and budget oversight of state institutions.

Download The Pantau Belanjawan Dataset

Download The Pantau Laksana Dataset